Three Valuation Methods

This article examines, compares, and contrast the different valuation approaches in determining business valuations.

There are three valuation methods that the valuation analyst may use to value an asset. The asset approach focuses on determining the value of an asset by the cost of replacing the asset. The market approach centers on examining an asset by comparing it with other identical or similar assets. And the income approach deals with analyzing future economic benefits or cash flows based in today’s dollars. Each approach is unique to the asset that is being valued, thereby, the analyst needs to determine what’s the best approach for each asset.

Three Valuation Methods

Introduction to the Three Valuation Methods

Valuations have significant relevance in many different areas, e.g. mergers and acquisitions, legal and tax purposes, corporate finance, portfolio management, and even real estate investments. No two valuations are exactly the same. Valuation reports are the measuring guide to those who need it. Value is the firm value that consists of shareholder value and fundamental value (Kumar, 2016). There are three primary approaches to valuations; asset approach, market approach, and the income approach. Each approach may have a different assumption, based on its characteristics. And each approach will carry different insights into the valuation.

The Asset Approach of the Three Valuation Methods

The asset or cost approach centers on the replacement cost of the company. “The asset approach presents the value of all the tangible and intangible assets and liabilities of the company” (Hitchner 343). The asset approach is based on an entry price or cost to buy, rather than, an exit price or the price that it can be sold. The asset approach is determined by a replacement cost that is estimated based on what it may cost to replace the asset as new, that is, it “requires an estimate of the cost to reproduce or replace existing improvements” (Hitchner 369).

Asset Approach Example 1

For instance, suppose an analyst needs to estimate the fair value of a car mechanic business. In the asset approach, the car mechanic business involves the land, the building, the machinery, among other assets. In one of the assets, there’s a car lift that still is operational. Since the car lift system is tied to the specific business operation, there’s not a direct determination for a particular selling price. However, the analyst may determine through an estimate of what it would cost to replace the car lift and have it newly installed.

Let’s assume that a commercial grade car lift cost is $23,000 with a life of 30 years with a 15 percent salvage value (metal scrap, etc.). The previous car lift has been in use for 3 years. Therefore, the salvage value is $3,450. Furthermore, we can determine the depreciation value per year at $23,000 – $3,450/30 years = $652 per year. And since the car lift has been in service for 3 years, we calculate that the depreciation value after 3 years is $1,955. Therefore, this will give us adjusted replacement cost of $21,045 ($23,000 – $1,955). The asset approach works because the calculation of the asset can be determined and replaced with what it would cost new, in this case, $21,045.

Asset Approach Example 2

“Business valuation analysts often rely upon the work of other professionals during the process of a valuation engagement” (Hitchner 364). In commercial real estate, assume that a piece of real estate property entails the land, the building, and the parking lot. The asset approach would estimate the cost of purchasing similar real estate (land) and then the cost of the building construction with the parking lot. It would estimate the land value to the building of depreciated value (Sirmans and Jaffe).

By this, the reproduction cost of improvements would be estimated. That is the cost of constructing the improvements of the building, pavement, and other assets. Then you would calculate the estimate of loss in value to the improvements. That is the value of the building due to deterioration or depreciation value. Once that is complete, you will subtract the loss in value from the production cost (Sirmans and Jaffe). Lastly, add the depreciated building to the estimated land value which will give you the asset approach to property.

The asset approach requires that an estimate is performed of the cost to replace or reproduce the existing improvements (Hitchner).

Market Approach of the Three Valuation Methods

The market approach takes data from market prices and compares with other similar or identical assets. The market approach relies heavily on company sales transactions and companies that are publicly traded (Hitchner). The concept entails the determination of comparables or “comps.” That is, one company is compared to another or multiple companies that are similar or one transaction is compared to other transactions. The value of these companies is known because either they are publicly traded or recently sold (Hitchner). The market approach among corporate finance is the methodology mostly used (Nesvold, Nesvold, and Lajoux).

Further, the market approach is the principle of substitution, that is, a buyer would not pay more for an asset than they would pay for one that is similar in the marketplace (Hitchner).

For instance, by determining the share of a stock’s fair value, we would look at the most recent selling price of comparable shares of that stock. And because the shares of ownership are identical for the same company, the current selling price of each share shows a solid indication of fair value for the other shares.

The market approach uses data-driven stock prices to drive the process of publicly traded stock. This is due to the transparency that public companies provide. For instance, the value of Microsoft stock, as of Friday, March 29, 2019, quoted a share price at $117.94 per share. This is a very good fair value through the market approach. In contrast, privately owned businesses do not have transparency since their financial reporting is not published, therefore, not producing much data and trading in the stock market. Therefore, the market approach works extremely well with publicly traded companies that publish their financial data. Further, the valuation of a privately held company through the market approach will still use publicly traded companies for valuation. This is because of the transparency of financial data, thereby, comparing with identical or similar companies. Therefore, for assets that are traded in a public or a transparent market, the valuation through the market approach works well.

However, companies or assets presents a small proportion globally. In other words, through most valuations, there will be better valuation approaches than the market approach. For instance, in private small businesses or underdeveloped real estate where similarities are not traded, the market approach cannot be used. When the market approach cannot be used, the income approach or asset approach may be used to estimate the value of an asset.

Market Approach in Real Estate

In real estate, the market approach “is an estimate of value based on a process of comparing recent sales of similar in the surrounding or competing areas to the subject property” (Hitchner). There are five major categories of adjustments that reflect a market approach valuation, time, location, financing, conditions of sale, and physical characteristics (Sirmans and Jaffe).

Time. Sales are historical, in that, the comparables should reflect based on how things may have changed. For instance, has there been any new construction in the area? Or are there any other factors that would influence the value, e.g. inflation (Sirmans and Jaffe).

Location. Location is very important and can impact the value. Adjustments may be necessary based on the comparables of whether the asset is in a certain location, e.g. based on different neighborhoods. These adjustments should reflect value.

Financing. There are different methods of financing an asset. Understanding the behavior of the buyer may impact the prices on the market. Fair market value is determined by a willing buyer and a willing seller and any compulsion may impact that estimated value.

Conditions of sale. Essentially, this is asking the question of how motivated are the buyers and sellers? Motivation can play a factor in market price.

Physical characteristics. This involves many components, e.g. building size, rooms, lot size, etc.

Overall, the market approach is very adaptable and is considered a great way to value an asset that has transparency, financial data, and other resources available for the analyst. Otherwise, if the asset is private or data is not accessible, e.g. privately own business. The income approach may be more suitable to value the asset.

Income Approach of the Three Valuation Methods

The income approach is considered the most widely recognized when valuing a privately held business (Hitchner). It is considered the most common and the most appropriate valuation to use in most situations and it is considered to be the most difficult, in that, with the least amount of certainty. The income approach essentially is analyzing the future economic benefits of an asset in income based on today’s dollars, or present value (Holton and Bates). The income approach is basically a mathematical fraction, thereby, consisting of a denominator and a numerator. Where the numerator “represents the future payments of an investment, and the denominator represents a quantification of the associated risk and uncertainty of those future payments” or rate of return (Hitchner 118). The income approach tries to determine the future cash flow through the means of financial data to its current operations and future plans for those business operations. There are three commonly used methods within the income approach; discounted cash flow (DCF), capitalized cash flow (CCF), and excess cash flow (ECF).

Each method requires a numerator and a denominator, that is, a future cash flow (numerator) and the rate of return (denominator) (Hitchner). And each method is dependent on the present value. The DCF method uses a series of fractions, whereas, the CCF uses only a numerator and denominator. Moreover, the ECF is a hybrid, whereby, “the ECF is the “amount of cash flow available to all intangible assets” (Hitchner 119).

Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method

Essentially, the DCF method calculates the present value of future cash flows utilizing a discount rate. These adjustments may be applied, for instance, a business may be growing exponentially. According to Hitchner (2017), there are five categories of adjustments, ownership characteristics, GAAP departures and extraordinary, nonrecurring, and unusual items, nonoperating assets and liabilities and related income or expenses, taxes, and synergies from mergers and acquisitions. Further, each business’s individual cash flows are discounted to the present value through the discounted rate over a certain period of time. At that point, the asset that is being valued to determine the overall cash flow.

The income approach compared to the market approach or the cost approach requires more estimates and there is more uncertainty within the valuation of the asset. This is mainly due to future predictions. In other words, it is difficult to predict anything in the forthcoming years that the asset will operate. For instance, there is no coming of what the interest rates will be or any future for that matter.

The Conclusion to the Three Valuation Methods

Valuations play a significant role in many financial interests. Analyst faces many challenges as assets change with the ongoing economy. Overall, there are three valuation methods. The asset approach, whereby, the valuations are determined by the replacement of the asset. The market value approach, that is, retrieving data from public or through transparency measures and comparing the asset with similar or identical assets. And the income approach, which is, analyzing future economic cash flows in today’s present value. The income approach is the most difficult based on its uncertainty due to its futuristic predictions, however, the widely used approach. Each approach brings to the table a different toolbox for the analyst to determine a valuation.

References

Hitchner, James R. Financial Valuation: Applications and Models. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2017.

Holton, Lisa, and Jim Bates. Business Valuation for Dummies. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Publishing, Inc., 2009.

Kumar, Rajesh. Valuation: Theories and Concepts. New York, NY: Academic Press, 2016.

Nesvold, Peter H, Elizabeth B Nesvold and Alexandra R Lajoux. Art of M&A Valuation and Modeling: A Guide to Corporate Valuation. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Education, 2016.

Sirmans, C. F., and Austin J. Jaffe. The Complete Real Estate Investment Handbook. New York, NY: Prentice Hall Press, 1988.

 

This page may contain affiliate links. This website may contain content that comes from Amazon. This website and its pages are not intended to constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. The information on this website and its pages are not intended to constitute investment advice and all content are the views and opinions of the author(s), contributors, or administrators. Please read our disclaimer for more info.

Hi. My Name is

James Gheen

Welcome to the Bigger Investing website. I’m here to help you find the resources, motivation, and guidance for all entrepreneurial, investing, business, career endeavors, and more, so that you can invest in what’s most important. Your mind!

My focus is to equip you with expert sources, books, guides, articles, and more to help you achieve your personal goals.

Want to learn more? Take a look.

getabstract ad


Read in Graphics

Rich Dad Summit Ad

What Makes a Lifestyle Sustainable?

What Makes a Lifestyle Sustainable?

‍s the world enters its sixth mass extinction, it is more important than ever to develop sustainable solutions to reduce our collective impact. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a globally accepted framework to guide sustainable...

Why Do Companies Greenwash?

Why Do Companies Greenwash?

‍he concept of a sustainable lifestyle is all the rage these days. Virtually every article, blog post, and news story you’ll read about sustainable living inevitably touches on the topic of sustainability. And with good reason. A...

What Do You Call Someone Who is Eco-Friendly?

What Do You Call Someone Who is Eco-Friendly?

his is a term you've probably heard before. It seems like everyone is talking about being eco-friendly now. And with good reason. The world is in bad shape. Just look at any of the natural disasters that have struck the planet in recent months....

Is Eco-Friendly?

Is Eco-Friendly?

he past few years have witnessed a sea change in the global consciousness about the environment. People are now more conscious of the impact of their actions and choices on the environment. At the same time, the green movement has also become a...

Why is Going Green So Expensive?

Why is Going Green So Expensive?

‍‍here’s a reason why the most popular way to go green is not to drive a hybrid car, buy solar panels, or eat organic food. It’s because going green is expensive. It costs money. A lot of it. In many cases, it’s more expensive than...

What are the 17 Sustainable Development?

What are the 17 Sustainable Development?

‍he UN’s ‘Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a global initiative that seeks to help achieve the United Nations’ Agenda 2030 by setting out a plan of action to end poverty and end all forms of discrimination. They were launched at the...

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainable Development?

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainable Development?

ustainable development is a broad concept that can apply to many different things. It can mean different things to different people. Lately, it has become a buzzword. What does it mean, and how can you implement sustainable development in your own...

Which country is the Least Environmentally Friendly?

Which country is the Least Environmentally Friendly?

ou might assume that the most environmentally friendly country in the world is somewhere in the Nordics, with their love of clean air and water, and their progressive policies to protect the natural world. But you’d be wrong. In fact, the country...

Do You Need to Be Rich to Be Sustainable?

Do You Need to Be Rich to Be Sustainable?

ustainability is a critical component of any organization. Organizations of all types are striving for sustainability to ensure they have long-term viability and are able to continue operating for the long term. There are a number of ways to...

What Is The Biggest Obstacle To Sustainability?

What Is The Biggest Obstacle To Sustainability?

here are so many challenges in the world of sustainability and environmentalism. It can be frustrating and feel like a never-ending process. However, there are also so many amazing opportunities and places to look for inspiration. When you look...

What is the Main Aim of Agenda 2030?

What is the Main Aim of Agenda 2030?

he 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development was launched in September 2016 by UN member states as a ten-year plan to end poverty and protect the environment by 2030. The 2030 Agenda is a universal plan of action for the next fifteen years, with...

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainability?

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainability?

n its most basic sense, sustainability is the ability of an ecosystem to continue to produce the goods and services it provides year after year. In other words, sustainability is about ensuring that the earth’s natural resources — such as soil,...

What are the 5 Components of Sustainable Development?

What are the 5 Components of Sustainable Development?

he term sustainable development has been making its way into the general consciousness of the world over the past few years, and for good reason. It’s not every day that a new concept is introduced into the sphere of social, environmental, or...

Where Can I Read Sustainability?

Where Can I Read Sustainability?

nterest in sustainability is higher than ever. That’s because it is becoming a more common topic of conversation. More people are joining the movement to live more sustainable, green lifestyles. With this increase in interest, you can find almost...

What are 4 Types of Sustainable Development?

What are 4 Types of Sustainable Development?

‍ustainability is the practice of delivering services and goods without compromising the environment or future generations. Sustainable development is an umbrella term that encompasses many different types of sustainable practices. With...

What Does Sustainability Mean to You?

What Does Sustainability Mean to You?

nderstanding the world around us is essential if we want to live responsibly and positively impact it. The first step is to understand what sustainability means to you. This means that if we want to make changes in order to better protect our data...

What are the 3 Principles of Sustainability?

What are the 3 Principles of Sustainability?

ustainability, also known as sustainable development, is a philosophy that encompasses all of society's activities in an attempt to maintain the environment. It's about reducing waste and conserving resources so that the planet can continue to...

What Does Sustainable Living Look Like?

What Does Sustainable Living Look Like?

t’s a term often used to describe ways of life that are based on the principles of ecology, social justice, and community. There are many different sustainable living practices out there, and it can be hard to decide which is right for you. Here,...

Why is Sustainable Living Important?

Why is Sustainable Living Important?

ccording to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, sustainability is the ability to provide for the needs and wants of current and future generations. Living sustainably is a concept that’s gaining more and more popularity and acceptance across...

What does it Mean to be Living Sustainably?

What does it Mean to be Living Sustainably?

iving sustainably doesn't have to mean huge, life-changing decisions. It's more about what you eat, what kind of toiletries you use, and how you waste your time. All those things are important to you, and they have a big impact on your life and...

What Are Some Examples of Sustainable Living?

What Are Some Examples of Sustainable Living?

he term “sustainable living” is commonly used in the media. It’s a buzzword that has been adopted by many companies and organizations who are looking for ways to save money and still maintain a high quality of life. The idea of sustainable living...

What are the Steps in the System Selection Process?

What are the Steps in the System Selection Process?

hether you need a commercially packaged warehouse management system, a point of sale system, an inventory control system, or a direct-to-customer order management system, selecting the right system is a major undertaking. Best Books on Systems and...

What are the 4 types of Strategies Under Strategic Analysis?

What are the 4 types of Strategies Under Strategic Analysis?

s a business owner, you know that you need to make strategic decisions in order to succeed. But how do you know what type of decisions to make? And how do you determine the best strategy for your business? There are four types of strategies—and...

What are System Planning and Initial Investigation?

What are System Planning and Initial Investigation?

n the system planning and initial investigation, the main objective is to identify the most important requirements for the system. It is an important step to identify the relevant system requirements for the system as a whole, for the subsystems,...

What is Planning in System Development?

What is Planning in System Development?

lanning in system development is the process of designing, planning, and testing a software system. It can be used to develop automotive systems, healthcare systems, social networking platforms, and other digital systems. The goal is to create a...

What is a Strategic Planning System?

What is a Strategic Planning System?

 strategic planning system is a tool used by business owners and managers to plan, manage, and monitor their businesses. A SPS helps you understand your business and its potential threats, opportunities, and performance. It also helps you choose...

What are the Three Types of Planning?

What are the Three Types of Planning?

lanning is the process of designing, plotting, and executing an action or event to achieve the desired outcome. The three types of planning are: strategic, tactical, and operational. Tactical planning is an overarching plan that defines the...

What are the 4 types of Planning?

What are the 4 types of Planning?

he first step to business success is to decide how to define success for the company. In many cases, businesses aren't clear on what exactly they want to achieve, and this can lead to confusion as well as frustration when goals are not met....

What do you Mean Planning?

What do you Mean Planning?

lanning is all about decisions. There are lots of them, they happen every day, and each one has the potential to affect the future in some way. We should be good at making good decisions and we can't always be good at that. Planning helps us get...

What are Some Types of Systems?

What are Some Types of Systems?

 system is a collection of parts that work together to achieve a common goal. Systems can be physical or open, probabilistic or deterministic, and man-made or natural systems. Best Books on Systems and Planning What is a system? The term ‘system’...