Charismatic Leadership Theory

Charismatic Leadership TheoryT

he Charismatic Leadership Theory (CRL) is a theory about leadership developed by Michael E. Porter and Joseph E. Slater in a series of books beginning with Managing the New Dynamics of Competition: Strategies for Success (Porter and Slater, 1984).

Their original inspiration was a discussion between Porter and Marcel Bénabou about the leadership styles of Richard Nixon, John F. Kennedy, and Nikita Khrushchev.

They made the mistake of using the word “chaos” to refer to these different leadership styles.

The book “Managing the New Dynamics of Competition: Strategies for Success” by Porter and Slater was first published in 1984, and in it, Porter and Slater introduced the original term “charismatic leadership”, in the context of four facets of leadership.

There is a fundamental tension in the theory between the two ways of taking a long view of competition: e.g., by putting together a series of competitive advantages, and by developing a strategy to achieve world domination, according to the latter.

More recent works by Porter have tended to place greater emphasis on the former strategy.

One of Porter and Slater’s major ideas is that successful companies must create a distinctive product or service to capture a meaningful market share in a new industry.

The “core competencies” of the “pioneers” (leaders) of a new industry are important for understanding the competitive dynamics of an industry.

Champions (or early pioneers) act as “ideal entrepreneurs”, building and managing the initial stages of the industry.

There are two primary forces that propel the initial competitive dynamics of a new industry:

According to Porter and Slater, since the initial stages of a new industry are difficult, entrepreneurship requires qualities beyond traditional business success.

The concept of competitive advantage is central to the book.

According to the authors, the concept of competitive advantage is closely related to the concept of life cycle management.

CFOs (Chief Financial Officers) in large corporations must be able to establish the appropriate business model and rationalize cash allocation at all levels of the organization.

In order to do this effectively, they need to understand how to create a competitive advantage for the corporation in terms of cash flow.

Porter and Slater differentiate between:

The “circuit model” of competition was developed by Michael Porter and Joseph Slater and developed further by others, including Gerald B. Cutler, in the latter part of the 1980s.

Each competitor has a “circuit”, which connects to the “crossover points” of that competitor’s “circuit”.

Closest to the “crossover points” are the “criteria for success”.

An organization that satisfies the criteria for success is identified as “having an essential competitive advantage”, which may be improved by exploiting a product, service, or geographic position.

A competitor that successfully exploits the criterion for success through innovation is referred to as a “competitor”, not a “victim” or “suspect”.

The main concept of strategy in Porter and Slater’s model is “delegating authority” or “reciprocity”.

In this model, the successful organization is able to foster cooperation and give, give and give authority to its key “pioneers”, without any limit on how much authority is given to the pioneers.

As a result of this, the innovators grow their authority and capture more market share.

The introduction of innovation and competition further the “power base” that defines the fundamental competitive advantage of the organization.

This power base defines the value of the organization and how others perceive it.

At each moment of competitive advantage, the “strength” of the power base increases.

This power base is accumulated during the competitive advantage phase, or during the monopoly phase, but is generally spread thin across the organization.

Porter and Slater maintain that the key to success is to be able to “delegate authority to early, strong pioneers”, which is when they achieve the greatest authority.

The pioneers are those key innovators that have the ability to create the most value for the organization and must be able to quickly assess the situation and act with sufficient authority.

The model is used in a number of “pioneer” firms, most famously Amazon.

The governing principle in this model is reciprocity, which Porter and Slater call “the exchange of resources”.

When a pioneer has an “intellectual asset”, which may be a new idea or a new technique, it must share the asset with someone else.

Someone must receive the idea in return for his/her use of the idea.

Porter and Slater define this as “delegating authority” or “reciprocity”.

Delegating authority to early, strong pioneers improves the organization’s power base because it enables the organization to grow quickly, seizing market share.

As a result, the organization can achieve the highest returns for its capital.

Also, the more pioneers are effective, the more the organization has to invest in each of them, making it increasingly likely that someone will break through and become a powerful pioneer, further increasing the advantage for the organization.

However, reciprocity is not absolute.

The organization has the ability to withhold authority and to “clawback” it when it believes that the pioneer has misused its authority.

To do this, the organization must have clearly defined authority.

They will need to define the authority of each individual pioneer, including the degree of authority that the pioneer has over those below him/her, and define a quantifiable measure of quality.

The innovation of these pioneers and their subsequent innovativeness is therefore important for the “legitimation” of their authority.

When trying to optimize innovation, the organization must be very clear about who has the power and how that power is distributed among individuals.

Also, the organization needs to have a mechanism to mitigate challenges from other organizations, including:

In the strategy of several prominent organizations, reciprocity is “shared”: it is shared between all individuals and groups within the organization, as well as between the organization and external organizations.

The main organization that is described as a “competitor” in the late 1970s Bell System, where the “experts” who made the key decisions were senior executives who had built the “old organization”, and the managers of the new organization were “insiders”.

Cultural companies are seen as having an equal power base, with power only divided by competence.

This is distinct from the “autarchic” model of innovation, in which the power base is shared among a few key innovators who are experts.

The differentiation is based on the “non-expert” group’s ability to fulfill the social and personal goals of the “expert” group.

The most famous organization that is differentiated from the autarchic model of innovation is McDonald’s, where power is shared between many non-expert managers who interact in a “commonsense” manner.

Diversity is also important in this model.

Venture capitalists (VCs) invest in diversity.

They tend to invest in firms that show high levels of performance and demonstrate a willingness to look outside the organization to attract and recruit innovators.

Other organizations have tried to solve the problem of reciprocity by formalizing the process.

At first blush, this looks like a good idea.

But innovation theorists such as Porter and Slater argued that the institution of a “reciprocal authority” system is inherently ambiguous, and this ambiguity leads to poor performance.

A better solution is to devise a unique system for the entire organization to follow.

The genius of Amazon is that it has formalized an organization-wide innovation system.

The key innovation of the organization is based on process, which is then optimized through the use of formal processes.

Since innovation is done in teams, the organization has a unique process for coordinating all the processes that are needed for a given innovation.

Then it relies on general-purpose (rather than restricted) roles for individuals, to take the place of functional roles.

What is Charisma in Leadership?

“Charisma is the ability to get others to do what you want them to do or become as you desire them to be.”

Charm and presence go hand-in-hand. Charisma is a powerful tool in making other people feel comfortable and at ease around you. By putting on a person’s aura, you are able to understand their emotional state and therefore be able to interact with them.

Your presence can make people feel accepted and heard. Your presence, your presence of yourself as a person, makes people happy. The more comfortable and outgoing you are, the more confident they will feel around you. If you’re shy, most people won’t take the time to interact with you.

There are other things you can do that increase your ability to read people’s moods. Hugs are very calming and get others’ energy up. The opposite of that is strong body language that sends a message that you are angry or have something to say, which shuts down the person you’re with.

Final Thoughts on Charismatic Leadership Theory

There are multipl of leadership styles and theories. Charisma or the concept of being charismatic allows the leader to influence people by their charisma. Nevertheless, for some it may be easy, others it may come to them harder were training or developing will be needed. 

Do you want to learn more about charisma? Check out these Best Books on Charisma.

This page may contain affiliate links. This website may contain content that comes from Amazon. This website and its pages are not intended to constitute legal, financial, or tax advice. The information on this website and its pages are not intended to constitute investment advice and all content are the views and opinions of the author(s), contributors, or administrators. Please read our disclaimer for more info.

Hi. My Name is

James Gheen

Welcome to the Bigger Investing website. I’m here to help you find the resources, motivation, and guidance for all entrepreneurial, investing, business, career endeavors, and more, so that you can invest in what’s most important. Your mind!

My focus is to equip you with expert sources, books, guides, articles, and more to help you achieve your personal goals.

Want to learn more? Take a look.

getabstract ad


Read in Graphics

Rich Dad Summit Ad

What Makes a Lifestyle Sustainable?

What Makes a Lifestyle Sustainable?

‍s the world enters its sixth mass extinction, it is more important than ever to develop sustainable solutions to reduce our collective impact. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a globally accepted framework to guide sustainable...

Why Do Companies Greenwash?

Why Do Companies Greenwash?

‍he concept of a sustainable lifestyle is all the rage these days. Virtually every article, blog post, and news story you’ll read about sustainable living inevitably touches on the topic of sustainability. And with good reason. A...

What Do You Call Someone Who is Eco-Friendly?

What Do You Call Someone Who is Eco-Friendly?

his is a term you've probably heard before. It seems like everyone is talking about being eco-friendly now. And with good reason. The world is in bad shape. Just look at any of the natural disasters that have struck the planet in recent months....

Is Eco-Friendly?

Is Eco-Friendly?

he past few years have witnessed a sea change in the global consciousness about the environment. People are now more conscious of the impact of their actions and choices on the environment. At the same time, the green movement has also become a...

Why is Going Green So Expensive?

Why is Going Green So Expensive?

‍‍here’s a reason why the most popular way to go green is not to drive a hybrid car, buy solar panels, or eat organic food. It’s because going green is expensive. It costs money. A lot of it. In many cases, it’s more expensive than...

What are the 17 Sustainable Development?

What are the 17 Sustainable Development?

‍he UN’s ‘Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a global initiative that seeks to help achieve the United Nations’ Agenda 2030 by setting out a plan of action to end poverty and end all forms of discrimination. They were launched at the...

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainable Development?

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainable Development?

ustainable development is a broad concept that can apply to many different things. It can mean different things to different people. Lately, it has become a buzzword. What does it mean, and how can you implement sustainable development in your own...

Which country is the Least Environmentally Friendly?

Which country is the Least Environmentally Friendly?

ou might assume that the most environmentally friendly country in the world is somewhere in the Nordics, with their love of clean air and water, and their progressive policies to protect the natural world. But you’d be wrong. In fact, the country...

Do You Need to Be Rich to Be Sustainable?

Do You Need to Be Rich to Be Sustainable?

ustainability is a critical component of any organization. Organizations of all types are striving for sustainability to ensure they have long-term viability and are able to continue operating for the long term. There are a number of ways to...

What Is The Biggest Obstacle To Sustainability?

What Is The Biggest Obstacle To Sustainability?

here are so many challenges in the world of sustainability and environmentalism. It can be frustrating and feel like a never-ending process. However, there are also so many amazing opportunities and places to look for inspiration. When you look...

What is the Main Aim of Agenda 2030?

What is the Main Aim of Agenda 2030?

he 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development was launched in September 2016 by UN member states as a ten-year plan to end poverty and protect the environment by 2030. The 2030 Agenda is a universal plan of action for the next fifteen years, with...

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainability?

What are the 3 Pillars of Sustainability?

n its most basic sense, sustainability is the ability of an ecosystem to continue to produce the goods and services it provides year after year. In other words, sustainability is about ensuring that the earth’s natural resources — such as soil,...

What are the 5 Components of Sustainable Development?

What are the 5 Components of Sustainable Development?

he term sustainable development has been making its way into the general consciousness of the world over the past few years, and for good reason. It’s not every day that a new concept is introduced into the sphere of social, environmental, or...

Where Can I Read Sustainability?

Where Can I Read Sustainability?

nterest in sustainability is higher than ever. That’s because it is becoming a more common topic of conversation. More people are joining the movement to live more sustainable, green lifestyles. With this increase in interest, you can find almost...

What are 4 Types of Sustainable Development?

What are 4 Types of Sustainable Development?

‍ustainability is the practice of delivering services and goods without compromising the environment or future generations. Sustainable development is an umbrella term that encompasses many different types of sustainable practices. With...

What Does Sustainability Mean to You?

What Does Sustainability Mean to You?

nderstanding the world around us is essential if we want to live responsibly and positively impact it. The first step is to understand what sustainability means to you. This means that if we want to make changes in order to better protect our data...

What are the 3 Principles of Sustainability?

What are the 3 Principles of Sustainability?

ustainability, also known as sustainable development, is a philosophy that encompasses all of society's activities in an attempt to maintain the environment. It's about reducing waste and conserving resources so that the planet can continue to...

What Does Sustainable Living Look Like?

What Does Sustainable Living Look Like?

t’s a term often used to describe ways of life that are based on the principles of ecology, social justice, and community. There are many different sustainable living practices out there, and it can be hard to decide which is right for you. Here,...

Why is Sustainable Living Important?

Why is Sustainable Living Important?

ccording to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, sustainability is the ability to provide for the needs and wants of current and future generations. Living sustainably is a concept that’s gaining more and more popularity and acceptance across...

What does it Mean to be Living Sustainably?

What does it Mean to be Living Sustainably?

iving sustainably doesn't have to mean huge, life-changing decisions. It's more about what you eat, what kind of toiletries you use, and how you waste your time. All those things are important to you, and they have a big impact on your life and...

What Are Some Examples of Sustainable Living?

What Are Some Examples of Sustainable Living?

he term “sustainable living” is commonly used in the media. It’s a buzzword that has been adopted by many companies and organizations who are looking for ways to save money and still maintain a high quality of life. The idea of sustainable living...

What are the Steps in the System Selection Process?

What are the Steps in the System Selection Process?

hether you need a commercially packaged warehouse management system, a point of sale system, an inventory control system, or a direct-to-customer order management system, selecting the right system is a major undertaking. Best Books on Systems and...

What are the 4 types of Strategies Under Strategic Analysis?

What are the 4 types of Strategies Under Strategic Analysis?

s a business owner, you know that you need to make strategic decisions in order to succeed. But how do you know what type of decisions to make? And how do you determine the best strategy for your business? There are four types of strategies—and...

What are System Planning and Initial Investigation?

What are System Planning and Initial Investigation?

n the system planning and initial investigation, the main objective is to identify the most important requirements for the system. It is an important step to identify the relevant system requirements for the system as a whole, for the subsystems,...

What is Planning in System Development?

What is Planning in System Development?

lanning in system development is the process of designing, planning, and testing a software system. It can be used to develop automotive systems, healthcare systems, social networking platforms, and other digital systems. The goal is to create a...

What is a Strategic Planning System?

What is a Strategic Planning System?

 strategic planning system is a tool used by business owners and managers to plan, manage, and monitor their businesses. A SPS helps you understand your business and its potential threats, opportunities, and performance. It also helps you choose...

What are the Three Types of Planning?

What are the Three Types of Planning?

lanning is the process of designing, plotting, and executing an action or event to achieve the desired outcome. The three types of planning are: strategic, tactical, and operational. Tactical planning is an overarching plan that defines the...

What are the 4 types of Planning?

What are the 4 types of Planning?

he first step to business success is to decide how to define success for the company. In many cases, businesses aren't clear on what exactly they want to achieve, and this can lead to confusion as well as frustration when goals are not met....

What do you Mean Planning?

What do you Mean Planning?

lanning is all about decisions. There are lots of them, they happen every day, and each one has the potential to affect the future in some way. We should be good at making good decisions and we can't always be good at that. Planning helps us get...

What are Some Types of Systems?

What are Some Types of Systems?

 system is a collection of parts that work together to achieve a common goal. Systems can be physical or open, probabilistic or deterministic, and man-made or natural systems. Best Books on Systems and Planning What is a system? The term ‘system’...